Nice Film Club vs The Darkroom | Honest Comparison of Mail-In Film Labs
Inside the Nice Film Club lab
LAB COMPARISON · Checked October 2026

Nice Film Club
vs The Darkroom

Two mail-in labs with the same pixels up to 4K. Here’s what’s different once your roll reaches us.

WHERE THE EXPERIENCE DIFFERS

Both labs adjust every frame. This is the rest.

The Darkroom says it adjusts color, contrast and density on every frame, and so do we. These are the hands-on parts you’ll only find here.

Scanned the way you asked

01

Your scanner, your framing

Choose Noritsu or Fuji Frontier for each roll, and a standard crop, overscan, sloppy borders or full rebates on Frontier.

Digital contact sheet · iOS · Kodak Gold 200

02

Mark up the whole roll

Every order comes with a digital contact sheet. In our iOS app you can circle your picks with a wax pencil.

Every frame, looked at

03

Pro Scans, beyond 4K

Their top tier is Super, the same 4492 × 6774 as our 4K. Above that, a technician finishes Pro Scans by hand, frame by frame.

Finished by hand

04

Printed by hand in our darkroom

Optical prints enlarged by hand from your negatives onto photographic paper. The Darkroom doesn’t list optical prints.

TRY IT ON ONE ROLL →

THE SHORT VERSION

Same film in. A very different experience out.

The Darkroom is a trusted, affordable mail-in lab that has been processing film since 1976. Their Standard scan starts at $14 a roll, and they accept almost every film format imaginable.

Nice Film Club is a modern film lab and photo platform. We color-correct every frame individually, deliver your scans in shareable galleries with contact sheets and search, and offer membership pricing that makes us price-competitive or cheaper.

THE DARKROOM

A lab that scans your film.

SINCE

1976

FROM

$14 a roll for 1K-class scans

FILES

JPEG only, up to 4492 × 6774

SHIPPING

$6.95 round trip

FORMATS

35mm, 120, 110, 126, APS, sheet

NICE FILM CLUB

A lab that develops, scans and keeps your film.

EVERY FRAME

Color-corrected, every tier

FROM

$12.99 a roll for members; free membership for students

FILES

JPEG, plus TIFF at 4K (16-bit on Noritsu)

SHIPPING

Free to the lab; negatives back $6.99–$7.99

FORMATS

35mm, 120, 220, 620 and 110; ECN-2 motion picture

THE KEY DIFFERENCE

The Darkroom is a lab that scans your film. Nice Film Club develops your film, organizes your photos, and becomes part of how you work.

PRICE PER ROLL

Matched tier for tier.

Each column compares the same resolution. Every membership beats The Darkroom at 1K and 2K. At 4K, Very Nice and Super Nice cost less; The Darkroom costs less than Monthly, Scholar and Nice. Membership starts at $9.99 a month, and it’s free for students.

The DarkroomNo membershipMonthly / Scholar / NiceVery NiceSuper Nice

1K

vs their Standard · 1000 × 1500

The Darkroom
$14.00
No membership
$13.99
Monthly / Scholar / Nice
$12.99
Very Nice
$9.99
Super Nice
$8.99

All members save

2K

vs their Enhanced · 2000 × 3016

The Darkroom
$16.00
No membership
$17.99
Monthly / Scholar / Nice
$14.99
Very Nice
$11.99
Super Nice
$9.99

All members save

4K

vs their Super · 4492 × 6774

The Darkroom
$20.00
No membership
$29.98
Monthly / Scholar / Nice
$24.98
Very Nice
$14.98
Super Nice
$12.98

Very & Super Nice save

Pro Scan

Finished by hand

The Darkroom
No equivalent
No membership
$42.98
Monthly / Scholar / Nice
$34.98
Very Nice
$26.98
Super Nice
$19.98

Only at Nice

35mm C-41, develop and scan. Shared bar scale: $0–43. Per-roll prices apply after included credits; membership fees and shipping are separate. Nice Monthly Lite: $9.99/mo, 0 included rolls; Nice Monthly: $19.99/mo, 1 included roll per month; Nice Scholar: free for students and educators, 0 included rolls; Nice: $199.99/yr, 10 included rolls per year; Very Nice: $999.99/yr, 30 included rolls per year; Super Nice: $4999.99/yr, 90 included rolls per year.

PLUS SHIPPING

The Darkroom charges $6.95 round trip per order. Our label to the lab is free, and getting your negatives back is $6.99 for members or $7.99 without.

The Darkroom prices are from their order form, checked 16 October 2026. Member prices are the same on Nice Monthly Lite, Nice Monthly, Nice Scholar and annual Nice.

35mm frame · Pixels drawn to scale
■ Nice Film Club · □ The Darkroom
4K4492 × 6774Theirs 4492 × 6774
2K2000 × 3016Theirs 2048 × 3072
1K1000 × 1500Theirs 1024 × 1536

Pro Scan uses the same 4K files, finished by hand, frame by frame.

01 · RESOLUTION

Matched pixel for pixel. Not file for file.

The Darkroom’s Standard, Enhanced and Super scans line up with our 1K, 2K and 4K. Their Super and our Noritsu 4K are the same 4492 × 6774 on 35mm.

The difference is what you get at each size. Our 4K includes TIFF files, 16-bit on Noritsu and 8-bit on Frontier, while theirs is JPEG only. Above 4K sits our Pro Scan, finished by hand frame by frame, and The Darkroom has nothing like it.

VERDICT

Nice Film Club leads on files and the top tier.

Same resolutions at 1K, 2K and 4K. TIFFs at 4K, and Pro Scans beyond it.

CHOOSE 4K ON YOUR NEXT ROLL →

Scanned your way

Choose the look.
Keep the edges.

Two scanners, different characters. Explore how your 35mm film can look — right down to the border.

Fuji Frontier

Classic lab color, with more of the negative in the frame. Choose a clean crop, organic borders or the full rebate.

8-bit TIFFs at 4K / Pro · 35mm framing shown

Explore all scanning options
C-41 35mm Frontier full-rebate scan with the film edge visible.

Full rebates · Sprocket holes, edge print, the whole frame.

More room to edit? 4K includes JPEG + TIFF. Pro Scans add custom color and tonal work.

Frontier and full rebates are optional add-ons. The Darkroom: no scanner choice listed in its published scan options.

Rush development + scanning

Your scans.
One business day.

For the rolls you need sooner.
Developed and scanned by our lab.

Rush development + scanning for C-41 and B&W.
Excludes E-6 and ECN-2. Shipping time is separate.
The Darkroom does not offer rush service.

About rush service

02 · AFTER THE SCAN

A gallery built to share.

The Darkroom delivers scans to a private web gallery, free for 60 days and then $18 a year, plus an app rated 3.7★ with reported crashes and download problems.

We deliver your scans in shareable galleries with digital contact sheets, search and permanent hosting. Over time your gallery becomes a searchable archive of everything you’ve shot on film.

VERDICT

Nice Film Club leads on the digital experience.

Galleries, contact sheets, search, shareable links and unlimited hosting, built for photographers.

Your online gallery

IN FAIRNESS

Where The Darkroom wins.

We believe in honest comparisons. The Darkroom has real strengths, and for some photographers they’ll matter most.

Lab35MM120220620110126APSSHEET
The Darkroom●●●●●●●●
Nice Film Club●●●●●———

Both labs accept 35mm, 120, 220, 620 and 110. The Darkroom also accepts 126, APS and sheet film.

$20

CHEAPER AT 4K

Their Super scan is $20. Our 4K is $24.98 for members and $29.98 without.

1976

FIFTY YEARS RUNNING

A trusted, established lab with minimal friction.

A Nice Film Club technician reviewing photographic prints and contact sheets.

The Nice difference

More than a download.

Scans to make your own. A gallery to keep them together. Prints to live with.

Start with one roll

Membership is optional.

A few more things

Questions, answered.

How do I switch from The Darkroom?

There’s nothing to cancel. Place an order, choose your scan size, scanner and framing, print the free label to our lab and mail your film.

Is your 4K the same as their Super scan?

In pixels, yes: both are 4492 × 6774 on 35mm. Our 4K comes with TIFF files (16-bit on Noritsu, 8-bit on Frontier), and The Darkroom delivers JPEG only. Their Super is $20 a roll; our 4K is $24.98 for members or $29.98 without.

Is Nice Film Club more expensive than The Darkroom?

It depends on scan size. Members pay less at 1K ($12.99 vs $14) and 2K ($14.99 vs $16). At 4K The Darkroom is cheaper: $20 against our $24.98 for members. They charge $6.95 round-trip shipping; our label to the lab is free, and negatives back are $6.99 for members or $7.99 without.

Do you develop 110, APS or sheet film?

Yes, we develop 110 film, along with 35mm, 120, 220 and 620. For 126, APS or sheet film, The Darkroom is a good choice.

Do I get my negatives back?

Yes, if you want them. We mail negatives back for $6.99 for members or $7.99 without.

What’s a digital contact sheet?

Every order comes with one: the whole roll laid out on a single sheet in your gallery, on the web and in our iOS app, where you can circle your picks with a wax pencil.

Try us on your next roll.

Same 4K files, plus Pro Scans, darkroom prints and a contact sheet you can mark up. Membership from $9.99 a month.

Join The Community

Stay up to date on all the Nice organized
content, features and local events.

© 2026 Meru Labs LLC